Expert Service

Whether your Hyundai is in need of repair or it's simply time for your next scheduled maintenance, our expert team of service professionals will take care of everything and get you back on the road in no time.

Schedule Service

Factory-trained technicians

Our certified technicians are experts on maintaining your Hyundai to factory standards, and are highly trained to diagnose and repair any issues to get it running like new again.

Genuine OEM parts

From brake pads and discs to suspension components and more, our Genuine OEM Hyundai parts ensure both a perfect fit and long-lasting performance.

State-of-the-art equipment

Our service center features state-of-the-art equipment and diagnostic tools, so you can be confident that the job will be done right the first time.

Exceptional service

We pride ourselves on providing exceptional service 100% of the time. We know that your car is your livelihood, so we want to get you back on the road with your Hyundai running its best.

Service Tools

Schedule a Service

Make an appointment

Service Specials

See what's new

Ask a Tech

Send us a message

Parts Department

Find parts

Safety Recalls

View recalls

Owners Assurance

Our promise

Service Specials

Oil & Filter Change

$10.00 OFF

• Replace engine oil per specifications (up to 5 quarts)*
• Install a Hyundai oil filter
• Check/adjust vital fluids
• FREE multi-point inspection

*Synthetic oil extra. Check the engine oil regularly between recommended oil changes. The engine oil and filter should be changed at the intervals specified in the maintenance schedule. Plus taxes and applicable fees. Prices may vary by model. Please present coupon at time of write-up. Cannot be used with any other applicable offer. Hazardous waste fee if applicable. Coupon has no cash value. Valid only at John Amato Hyundai. - Coupon expires 12/25/2026

Expires: 12/25/2026

Discount on Vehicle Service

SAVE

Save on vehicle service (including parts and labor)
• Spend $100.00 – $199.99 and save $10
• Spend $200.00 – $299.99 and save $20
• Spend $300.00 – $399.99 and save $30
• Spend $400.00 or more and save $40

*Discount excludes tire purchases. Plus taxes and applicable fees. Prices may vary by model. Please present coupon at time of write-up. Valid only at John Amato Hyundai. Cannot be used with any other applicable offer. Hazardous waste fee if applicable. Coupon has no cash value. - Coupon expires 12/25/2026

Expires: 12/25/2026

Transmission Fluid Flush $375

Flush the transmission fluid and replace it with new fluid. Includes a 34-point inspection.

Cabin Air Filter Replacement $89.95 plus tax

Inspect and replace the cabin air filter.

Wiper Blade Replacement $51 plus tax

Inspect and replace the front wiper blades.

4-Wheel Alignment $179.95 plus tax

AND a coupon for $25 off!
Inspect and perform a 4-wheel alignment. Includes a 34-point inspection.

Tire Rotation & Brake Inspection $29.95 plus tax

Rotate the tires and perform a brake inspection. Includes a 34-point inspection.

Full Synthetic Oil Change $89.95 plus tax/fees

Get up to 5-quarts of High Mileage or Full Synthetic oil & a Hyundai oil filter. Includes a 31-point inspection.

Hyundai Battery

$20.00 OFF

Specifically engineered for your Hyundai.*
• Superior reliability
• Peak performance
• Ultimate peace of mind

*Valid at our Parts Department only. Plus taxes and applicable fees. Prices may vary by model. Please present coupon at time of write-up. Valid only at John Amato Hyundai. Cannot be used with any other applicable offer. Hazardous waste fee if applicable. Coupon has no cash value. - Coupon expires 12/25/2026

Expires: 12/25/2026

Brake Special

$20.00 OFF

• Replace front or rear brake pads and resurface front or rear rotors*
• Inspect discs, calipers, brake lines, hoses, master cylinder and wheel cylinders
*Rotor replacement, master cylinder, wheel cylinder and caliper repair or replacement extra if needed.

Plus taxes and applicable fees. Prices may vary by model. Please present coupon at time of write-up. Valid only at John Amato Hyundai. Cannot be used with any other applicable offer. Hazardous waste fee if applicable. Coupon has no cash value. - Coupon expires 12/25/2026

Expires: 12/25/2026

Hyundai Multi-Point Inspection

FREE

Our Hyundai-trained technicians will inspect your vehicle and let you know if anything needs attention. Call us for details.

Plus taxes and applicable fees. Prices may vary by model. Please present coupon at time of write-up. Valid only at John Amato Hyundai. Cannot be used with any other applicable offer. Hazardous waste fee if applicable. Coupon has no cash value. - Coupon expires 12/25/2026

Expires: 12/25/2026

Our facilities and amenities

With comfortable seating, free Wi-Fi, abundant coffee and plenty of snacks, we make waiting for your vehicle a relaxing experience. And for your ultimate convenience, our restrooms are always clean and sanitary.

Schedule Service

Expert staff and technicians

From our friendly and knowledgeable staff to our certified technicians who are the experts on maintaining and repairing your Hyundai, our Service Center is 100% dedicated to keeping your vehicle running like new.

Schedule Service

Hyundai Service Tips & Videos

Vehicle maintenance

Vehicle maintenance

From oil changes to rotating your tires, staying on top of factory-recommended maintenance will keep your Hyundai running its best.

Learn More
Complimentary care

Complimentary care

Enjoy 3 years of complimentary maintenance at your local Hyundai dealer on any new 2020-2025 Hyundai model year.

Learn More
Educational content

Educational content

The more you know about your Hyundai, the more enjoyment you’ll get out of ownership and the more prepared you’ll be in an emergency.

Learn More
Memory reset

Memory reset

Ensure that you maintain an optimal driving position at all times by knowing how to use and reset the driver’s seat memory.

Learn More

Customer Reviews


John Amato Hyundai

Google logo
Google Oct 20, 2026

Every single person at this dealership is so pleasant and helpful! I would recommend them to everyone!

Google logo
Google Oct 19, 2026

Google logo
Google Oct 13, 2026

Amazing customer service!!

Google logo
Google Oct 9, 2026

I brought my recently purchased used Ioniq 5 to the service department for a rattle. I knew that it was going to be extremely hard to find the root cause. It took a while, but I applaud John the manager of the service department for continuing to push for resolution. They did find the rattle, remedied it and exceeded my expectations. I couldn’t love my car more especially now that it’s quieter. Highly recommend them.

Google logo
Google Oct 8, 2026

Great place to service your vehicle. Feels like family.

Google logo
Google Sep 30, 2026

I have always had a great experience coming to John Amato Hyundai for any service work I have!!

Google logo
Google Sep 24, 2026

Always great service and customer service.

Google logo
Google Sep 22, 2026

All went as promised.

Google logo
Google Sep 18, 2026

This place was recommended to me, so I took a chance, and I’m really happy I did. They were friendly and honest and the price was right. Anytime I have a question or a problem, I will definitely come back.

Google logo
Google Sep 18, 2026

Because of both April’s and Trenton’s superior service, attention to detail, professionalism, and kindness, I will be returning to this location for my 2024 Tucson Limited’s service!

Google logo
Google Sep 17, 2026

I was told the car would be ready in two hours. Than the next day at 12pm. Then the next day in the morning because they didn’t have the part. I was without my car for three weekdays while working. Called to complain. Nothing done about it.😠

Google logo
Google Sep 17, 2026

Google logo
Google Sep 14, 2026

Their shuttle van driver likes to drive like an idiot and not pay attention when making turns cutting people off

Google logo
Google Sep 12, 2026

They sold me a car that wasn’t ready to be sold. They didn’t replace the shifting cable before having it on the lot. They had the part but failed to install it before having it on the lot . The car fax was NOT up to date. Not only that my check engine light came on 2 weeks after Buying the vehicle. My breaks are still squeaking and I had it in the shop three times for multiple different issues related to the car breaks being one. they don’t fix anything you ask them to. The service department have ... Read More

Google logo
Google Sep 4, 2026

Google logo
Google Sep 2, 2026

An easy pickup, replaced my entire engine under warranty and my car works great again 😊

Google logo
Google Sep 1, 2026

Google logo
Google Aug 26, 2026

Brian Butler is one of the best auto repair service agents I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with. He is always cheerful, prompt, courteous, communicative, and seems never flustered by anything. Agents like Brian are the reason why I choose to return to Amato for service. Thank you!

Google logo
Google Aug 25, 2026

Google logo
Google Aug 21, 2026

Great service

Google logo
Google Aug 19, 2026

On Sunday July 19th 2026 my cars air conditioning stopped working. The following morning, I was unable to unlock my car with my key fob. After gaining access using the key, my car had no power and would not start. Roadside assistance came and jumped the car and I drove it to the shop. Within a few days I was told that my air conditioning unit needed a part that was on back order. I was later told that there was no estimate time for the arrival of the parts needed to repair the air conditioning unit. My car was in ... Read More

Google logo
Google Aug 17, 2026

April char Michelle solid great service and they actually did a super Superior job great job God bless you guys

Google logo
Google Aug 12, 2026

Great, attentive service....especially with needed urgency.....thank you!!

Google logo
Google Aug 7, 2026

I’m just an everyday American Man who doesn’t think JAH had my best interest at heart. Every since I bought the car I’ve had it serviced by them, and not once did they say anything about doing anything else other than an oil change, but after getting to 187000 plus miles I questioned about a tuneup, and was told that should be done/checked every 90000 miles. When I purchased the car it had 84000 miles on it, so today when I come in for my oil change I’m told about this forever warranty thing concerning the transmission, fuel ... Read More

Google logo
Google Aug 5, 2026

I recently purchased a used Jeep Wrangler and after a few concerns and unexpected hiccups, I started to worry about my decision. Thankfully, BJ (General Manager) stepped in and completely changed my experience. BJ made sure every issue was addressed/resolved and his commitment to customer satisfaction was truly impressive. He went above and beyond to make things right and kept me informed throughout the whole process. He genuinely cared about ensuring I was happy with my purchase. I couldn't be more thankful for the assistance, professionalism, and outstanding customer service. It's rare to find someone who takes ... Read More

Google logo
Google Aug 5, 2026

I came in to get two tires plugged there’s not a single car in service. I asked some guy when I came in if they could help me out with a tire plug. The service advisor proceeds to tell me this is a job that’s going to take a few days. Now I’m not an idiot I know how to plug tires but if you didn’t want to do the job or weren’t available why couldn’t you say that instead of talking to me like I’m an idiot and don’t understand the ... Read More

Google logo
Google Aug 4, 2026

I’m very disappointed with how this situation was handled. Although the warranty work was completed, the emissions-related issues that brought me to the dealership were not resolved. My vehicle had only approximately 36,000 miles and was experiencing issues with the flow control valve and EV-related sensor that caused it to fail emissions. After the dealership was unable to resolve the problem, I had to seek assistance from additional mechanics and ultimately obtain a state emissions waiver. I also contacted the dealership regarding the warranty extension letter I received, but I did not receive a timely response, and the extension ultimately ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jul 30, 2026

Google logo
Google Jul 29, 2026

I can always rely on good service for my 2024 Tucson at Amato Hyundai during my summers in the Milwaukee area. April was especially helpful on my most recent visit. Everything is looking good, and I appreciated knowing what services to keep in mind for future appointments.

Google logo
Google Jul 26, 2026

They did an excellent job, kept good communication throughout, and the price was reasonable!

Google logo
Google Jul 21, 2026

We had a great experience with John Amato service department! Michael L who worked with us was wonderful! Explained what needed to be done on our SUV and the timeframe it might take to get the work done which ended being even less than expected. Would recommend their service department for any work you need done.

Google logo
Google Jul 18, 2026

Google logo
Google Jul 14, 2026

I had a great experience buying a car here! The whole process was incredibly smooth and easy. I was very satisfied with the service, and I especially want to highlight Ade and Sam for their friendly, helpful, and professional work. Highly recommend this dealership!

Google logo
Google Jul 14, 2026

We drove almost 3 hours to purchase our new vehicle. The experience was good. The salesman said they dont sell cars without making sure tires are atleast 50% tread left. Our first inspection of the vehicle we were told the tires are going to need to be replaced soon and definitely before winter. Definitely disappointed with this.

Google logo
Google Jul 13, 2026

Google logo
Google Jul 7, 2026

Google logo
Google Jul 4, 2026

One of the best automotive service teams I have ever worked with. I highly recommend them. Professionalism and positive attitude of service staff is exceptional.

Google logo
Google Jul 1, 2026

Mike Evans has always been equitable, knowledgeable and a pleasure to work with. His staff is just as fantastic as he is.

Google logo
Google Jul 1, 2026

This dealership is awful. Specifically, the service department. Please take your car literally anywhere else. They had my Hyundai for a month, claiming they didn’t know what was causing the issues with it stalling while driving. For multiples days in a row, they would not get back to us on what was going on with the car. After a month, when we finally got the car back, they left grease stains all over the front passenger seat. They said they “might” be able to get the car back in, in a month to clean the stains they left. There ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jun 30, 2026

Very friendly. Very honest. Upfront about everything. A lifetime warranty just for getting your maintenance done with them? A phenomenal deal... Especially since they are throwing in free oil changes and tire rotations. Joe was so easy to deal with and we never felt like we were being upsold or being pushed into anything we didn't want. Edit: About 6 weeks after purchase the AC system stopped working. They had repaired the AC system right before we took delivery of our used Nissan Pathfinder. We are on the hook for an additional $1000 because they charged $200 just to look at it ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jun 29, 2026

The locking lug fell off the rear passenger side wheel after my tire rotation last Thursday. What should the torque be on those, as I am going to check all of the lug nuts. Thanks Kevin Piquette

Google logo
Google Jun 26, 2026

Great Customer Service.

Google logo
Google Jun 25, 2026

Google logo
Google Jun 18, 2026

I had no problems with them...they did exactly what they said they were going to do... I would recommend them

Google logo
Google Jun 15, 2026

I’m always happy with the service, recommendations, and quick turnaround. Michael is knowledgeable, honest, and truly has his customers best interests in mind. I know I can trust his recommendations and never feel pressured into unnecessary services. I wouldn’t go anywhere else and highly recommend Amato in Menomonee falls to anyone looking for reliable, professional service!

Google logo
Google Jun 15, 2026

Google logo
Google Jun 15, 2026

Google logo
Google Jun 11, 2026

My sales person Sam was great from the time I walked into John Amato Hyundai. He made me feel comfortable and let me know I could call him with any questions or if I needed anything. He has stood behind that statement. I brought my car in for a recall. The service department handled it, my car was taken care of within an hour while I sat comfortably in the waiting room. I was given an explanation of what was fixed and my car was returned to me after they washed it. My experience was great and I highly recommend ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jun 5, 2026

A friend was supposed to have the same update as me to our new 2026 Tucson SEL but a bad accident on the highway was preventing him from making his time slot and called me to let me know because 9 out of 10 times I would have traveled the same route. Thinking outside the box, I called John Amato’s service center and explained to John the service manager the situation and asked if we could switch time slots so my friend could still get the update. I had a 1 hour later time slot than my friend. Without hesitation, John, the service-manager ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jun 3, 2026

Great team

Google logo
Google May 28, 2026

Sold my family member a car with a bad engine (among other issues) and said could take months to fix. Never any rentals either to help take the stress off any time there is an issue with this vehicle . Mind you they paid for a warranty thats supposed to cover a rental. Despicable.

DealerRater logo
DealerRater May 20, 2026

Have been a customer for 10 years and they have always taken care of my needs for my 2015 Genesis. Michael LeClaire has been my advisor for about that long and always treats his customers like V.I.P.S. Great service team all around! Thank you for being there for me Amato Team!

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google May 19, 2026

Financed a vehicle from here not even a year ago ! I’ve had to replace two tires, the alternator, the battery and now fuel injectors !!!! It has not been a year !! I’m very disappointed and highly upset !!!

Google logo
Google May 13, 2026

The reason why we chose to come to John Amato Hyundai for all of our service needs is because of Michael LeClaire. He's been the greatest Advisor we've ever worked with. He listens to our concerns, needs and always accommodates us with true professionalism. We actually followed him from West Allis where we live to Menomonee Falls because he is just that awesome and trustworthy. Thank you Michael LeClaire for all you do. The Badillo Family

Google logo
Google May 7, 2026

Review Update: The wait times for my recalls are obnoxious. I was told 30 minutes on each of my last experiences and waited 1.5 hours last time and am now on an over two hour wait. I was just told ANOTHER 30 minutes. I brought work, but as a designer, there’s only so much I can do from here. This is unacceptable. In November 2025 we test drove a car with Josh. Long story, we bought near Kenosha, but wish we would have bought from this dealer. Cut to today, my CarPlay wouldn’t work. I stopped by John Amato and guess who ... Read More

Google logo
Google May 7, 2026

They don’t keep their word, 24-48 hours for a part turns into a week. And if you leave a review, BEWARE. They are rude and don’t care. Disrespectful and horrible customer service. Would never recommend.

Google logo
Google May 5, 2026

Had a great experience at this dealership drove an hour just because I didn’t feel pressured to purchase just like I would at any other dealership. If you’re looking for a great salesman ask for Sam. Sam went above and beyond throughout the whole process, truly a great guy! Recommend 10/10

Google logo
Google Apr 18, 2026

Sam made buying a car… enjoyable??? He communicated clearly every step of the way — no back and forth, no waiting around, no surprises. I always knew where things stood and what was coming next. Walked in, got it done, drove home happy, and more importantly, feeling like I got a fair deal. If you want someone who values your time and treasure, Sam (and the Amato team) are your guys. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I don’t know if I’d buy a car from anyone else — and I’ve been telling people to go find Sam.​​​​​​​​​

Google logo
Google Apr 2, 2026

Great Service here always. I have a 2022 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid Limited and I only trust Amato Hyundai with my car's maintenance and service. Top class customer service!

Google logo
Google Apr 1, 2026

The whole buying experience was a breeze. A shoutout in particular to Radio Joe in sales for his exceptional candor and sincere helpfulness. But the manager and even the finance officer were also very friendly and transparent... none of the usual sleaziness of car salesmen!

Google logo
Google Apr 1, 2026

Service wasn't great. Brought my car in for a tire replacement and it took 5+ days to complete. During that time they noted another issue with the car and stated it had been repaired. Check engine light came back on the 2nd time I started my car. Was told it was likely a gas cap leak and that there would be a $225 charge to check it. Regardless of what "policies" are, I would think that common sense would prevail for the 5 minutes it would take to check the gas cap.

Google logo
Google Apr 1, 2026

Our sales guy Joe was outstanding! He understood what we wanted and how much we wanted to pay, got it done. But, CAUTION with their finance person Rob - he will play games! And heaven forbid you change your mind on the extended warranty - he must already have his commission amount for it spent immediately:( I told him bright and early Monday morning after purchasing the car Saturday that we decided we did not want it after all because we are planning on trading the car in again in about 2 or 3 yrs, like we had done with our last 2. ... Read More

Google logo
Google Mar 11, 2026

Extremely disappointing experience with the service department at John Amato Hyundai. Every time I brought my vehicle in for a technology-related issue, the immediate assumption was that the problem was caused by operator error. I was repeatedly warned about high labor costs to “fix” the issue if it wasn’t covered under warranty, which felt more like a scare tactic than honest service. The worst experience was when my engine completely failed(November 2025). Instead of asking if I was the original owner, the service advisor flat-out assumed I wasn’t and immediately said Hyundai probably would not approve the warranty. ... Read More

Google logo
Google Feb 24, 2026

Our sales associate, Sam Othman, was extremely helpful. After communicating with him via text he brought the vehicle we were interested in test driving to his location from another location. He was very helpful and got the exact model we wanted from another dealership. The entire process at Amato was simple and efficiently handled.

Google logo
Google Jan 16, 2026

Google logo
Google Dec 14, 2025

BEWARE BEWARE BEWARE ‼️‼️‼️ Save your time and save your money. This dealership has poor communication, poor management, poor customer service and is all about profit. I have a 2008 Toyota Avalon Limited with 72,000 miles in mint condition that I wanted to trade he offered $500 for it then when I showed offense he went up to $4,000 which is still under value 3 other dealerships have all offered well above. This dealership just wants to sell cars while doing the most Minimum amount of work to them as well so if you do choose to buy a vehicle have a mechanic with you to ... Read More

Google logo
Google Nov 21, 2025

2025 palisade, my first oil change 5,000 miles, I made an appointment I was on time, it took 2 hours to do an oil change??? I talked to the service manager to find out why it took so long?? he said it was busy?? but I made an appointment!!! Then he said normally takes 2 hours to do an oil change?? I 😂, did the mechanic take too long? did he over schedule? Are they understaffed?? I hope they figure it out soon!! No answers? just a bad attitude!! 😕 For my second oil change I went to Walmart. had my oil changed and it took 22 ... Read More

Google logo
Google Nov 21, 2025

I’m extremely disappointed with my experience at John Amato Hyundai. When I purchased my vehicle, everything seemed fine—until I drove it home. That’s when I noticed a loud rattle coming from the passenger-side door, something that was clearly already there when I bought the car. I didn’t notice it at the dealership, but it became obvious as soon as I took it home. On top of that, they didn’t even give me a full tank of gas when I purchased the vehicle, which is basic customer service at almost any dealership. The detailing and vacuuming ... Read More

Google logo
Google Nov 12, 2025

I would give them a zero at this point old spark plugs and food in my engine compartment after big bucks spent on service. and car was not even fixed correctly. Brought it back in charged a 2nd diagnostic fee which revealed stuff that should have been identified and fixed on the original work. There service department I would not trust any longer to do good work. I am assuming new people as we have not had issues in the past UPDATE: Service manager did respond and did say sorry for the old spark plugs being left behind. Said he ... Read More

Google logo
Google Nov 5, 2025

Broken Promises and Poor Service After a $30,000 Purchase We purchased a Tahoe for $30,000 and were promised a smooth, professional experience—but that’s not what we got. During the sales process, our salesman Jaun failed to even show up for two of our scheduled appointments, including the final sale appointment. (We should have taken the hint here to run!) When we finally picked up the vehicle—after they said it had been detailed—the tank was nearly empty and the car was actually dirtier than when we test drove it. They apologized and promised three free oil changes for the ... Read More

Google logo
Google Oct 22, 2025

Absolutely Disgusted by the Sales Manager, Dan — Amato Hyundai in the Falls! Get rid of Dan, and the problem is gone. I have never in my life been treated with such disrespect by anyone in a professional setting. The sales manager, Dan, was arrogant, rude, and completely out of line. His behavior was downright unacceptable. The way he spoke to me — and to his own employees — was appalling. It’s like he gets some kind of satisfaction out of belittling people. You would think a person in his position would have at least a basic understanding of customer service, but ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jul 19, 2025

Ripped me off on top of that - pathetic service. Do not recommend at all. I had a flat tire, I called couple of places near by and none had the tire to replace. I called them as well and said drop the car and we will get replaced in a day as they also need to order the tire and next day will get the will be installed. Next day received the call that it was past cutover window for ordering the tire so couldn’t get it hence will be next day. Next day I have to follow ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jul 3, 2025

Do not recommend this service department. Took a car in to get looked at for a warranty issue on a vehicle with less than 5k miles. They were unable to fix it in a reasonable time so we went to pick it up to be looked at elsewhere, charged me an inspection fee and gave me back my vehicle with dirty handprints on the beige interior near the work area and a new lump in the fabric where they attempted to look at the issue and closed it back up incorrectly. Tried to reach out to the general manager via ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jun 8, 2025

Absolutely terrible. No indication that anything was off when we made the appointment and spent time test driving cars. Salesman was fine and let us do our thing. Answered questions but gave us space. After deciding on one but wanting time to think about it, the pressure was on. They just kept going and going. The manager was the worst and looked like he just had his 21st birthday the week before. Just pushed and pushed and pushed. Refused to see that we were tired and needed to take a breather. How they do not know that this kind of ... Read More

Google logo
Google Mar 29, 2025

DO NOT TAKE YOUR CAR HERE! If I could give this service department a zero, I would. Dropped my car off on a Saturday and told them that I would be picking it up next Saturday when I got back into town from my vacation. I did not hear from anyone on Monday, so I called on Tuesday to get an update. Was told my advisor was out but someone else would call me within an hour. Nobody called me. Finally heard from Trenton on Wednesday that my car required work; they had the after market parts and could get ... Read More

Google logo
Google Mar 13, 2025

Had my oil changed here last month and shortly and by shortly I mean the day after my oil change my car was leaking oil. Took it back they said they fixed the issue as it was just a torn seal. No big deal right. WRONG! I changed my oil today myself like I usually always do and to my surprise “NOT” they never cleaned up all that oil from their mistake so there was oil all over the underside of my car. What a disgusting mess I had to clean up. Never take your car here for service unless ... Read More

Google logo
Google Mar 12, 2025

If I could give zero stars to the service dept I would. Long story short, go to another Hyundai dealer. Poor service, terrible communication, way too long wait times. My car under warranty had some parts replaced to fix a loud thudding noise. The noise appeared again shortly after service. I do not believe this was the problem. Took them a week to figure this "fix" out. The only good thing that came from this experience was a nice loaner Santa Fe for the week. I will not be returning to this dealer. Ended up taking to another ... Read More

Google logo
Google Feb 27, 2025

My car engine was running very rough. had a diagnostic done at O'Reilly auto parts. Said the spark plugs were bad or it could be the coil on cylinder 4 of the engine. Had it towed to amato Hyundai in the Falls. They said the coil was bad and recommended the spark plugs be replaced also. Had someone recommend a local auto shop. Had it taken there. Was told the coil was fine and the spark plugs were bad. Also found a minor oil leak that required a new gasket. Was told there was no way Amato did a 99 point ... Read More

Google logo
Google Feb 14, 2025

Sold a car with $1700 worth of issues , buyer beware these guys have no integrity I just bought this car and check engine light comes on and then they want to charge me for a diagnosis test..Take your money elsewhere no one at John Amato Hyundai values the customer

Google logo
Google Jan 28, 2025

BEWARE: Horrible service. management mocks you on the phone, don't come here or expect absolutely terrible customer service.

Google logo
Google Jan 14, 2025

Very disappointing experience. I brought my car in simply because my gas door was not opening, most likely because of the cold. I was told it would be a little bit before they would look at it. 4 hours go by and I call and I was told they would not look at it until the next day. When I questioned this I was reminded that I was told it would be "a little bit of time" as if I was incorrectly understanding what this meant. The actual conversation was, "we need you to leave it here for ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jan 10, 2025

Service experience was terrible! First and Only time I will be coming here. Had to come in for warranty work. Was referred here by a friend who just purchased a car from this dealership. Was quoted an hour on the phone for warranty work. Sat in lobby for 5 hours. At 2 hours I asked what is taking so long and was given the usual BS about it is taking longer than expected. Again, 5 hours I waited. The service rep did apologize and that was it. There is clearly a difference between the Sales Team, which has terrific reviews on Google vs ... Read More

Google logo
Google Aug 12, 2024

They’re absolute swindlers they don’t reveal the truth they’ll take your down payment process it and then send you back for the loan and won’t reveal your interest rate after they have done everything and there’s no chance of backing out their garbage

Google logo
Google Aug 6, 2024

Poor customer service I waited an hour before they even took my car back and I had a appt

Google logo
Google Jul 16, 2024

I made an appointment weeks ago to replace a broken door handle. Gave make model year and paint color. I came and they wasted an hour of my time with "inspection." Paid $150 for them to tell me that my door handle was broken and that they would have to order parts for it. Why not tell me up front? I assumed the would have had the parts since I was asked even for the car's color. I told them I was doing this just before moving to make moving easier. If I was just going to waste ... Read More

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Jun 18, 2024

Got a notice for a recall for my Hyundia. A year later the recall fix was finally ready. Called the dealer to schedule the fix for the recall. I received 2 reminder text for the service. I had a 7:15 am appointment. When I arrived the service advisor said they did not have the parts for the recall. I made it clear, when making the appointment, that I was coming in for the recall. They should have had the part! If not they should have a least called to reschedule the appointment so I didn't have to get up early and ... Read More

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google Jun 7, 2024

I take my car in for recalls Amato disables my alarm system and break my remote. I pull up everything is working I get a phone call my alarm won’t turn off. Store manager proceeds to tell me my car alarm was broke when I came in. I can’t even ride around without an alarm because the car will be stolen and if the alarm was broken and going off the service guy wouldn’t have taken the car. The first thing he said when he touched my car was they wouldn’t be able to install the ... Read More

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Mar 5, 2024

I have purchased two vehicles from John Amato Hyundai and have been very pleased both times. Staff have been very pleasant to work with both times, especially the first time when I was in a tougher financial spot then I am now.

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google Mar 1, 2024

These guys are an absolute joke! They changed the oil on my husband’s car and didn’t replace everything properly inside with the result that the engine leaked oil and ran dry. My husband got stranded with a broken car near Green Bay. Amato took no responsibility for any of it! We had to get rid of his Hyundai! Today I had my Hyundai booked in for a service. I booked online which gave me the option to book a pickup from my house. I called yesterday to confirm the pickup but today nobody came. When I called again ... Read More

Google logo
Google Feb 19, 2024

NEVER AGAIN!!! I took my daughter’s car in here to see if we fell under the class action lawsuit. Which Hyundai vehicles are included? The “Class Vehicles” are 2011–2019 model year Hyundai Sonata, 2013–2019 model year Hyundai Santa Fe Sport, and 2014–2015 and 2018–2019 model year Hyundai Tucson equipped with 2.0 liter and 2.4 liter genuine Theta II gasoline direct injection engines within OEM specifications. After paying $200 to determine whether it would be covered (it was not) They told me the car was finished and that we could pick it up. I paid the bill, got the keys and left the dealership. Upon leaving, the ... Read More

Google logo
Google Feb 15, 2024

Well the website says warranty forever but they don't actually give you that on a new car. Also, even though they claim 3yr 36k mile complimentary service, they will only do 4 services max and they will find any reason possible to deny it. Try to ask question and they answer something else, never can give a clear answer

Google logo
Google Feb 12, 2024

The dealership in Menomonie Falls failed to help replace a car I got from them that got totaled! So I went and Got a Car from another dealership with out No money down

Google logo
Google Feb 8, 2024

I cannot go back there. I've been a customer for many years and it's always a disappointing experience. Every. Single. Time. - Consistently slow service. 100% of the time they over-promise and under-deliver when it comes to estimating wait times. Today I got, "Your service will take about 45 minutes" (oil change and tire rotation). I left 1 hour and 22 minutes later. - Scheduled today's appointment online. In addition to the oil change/tire rotation, I selected State Emissions Test. However, they do not perform emissions testing. Had I known this, I would have gotten all these services ... Read More

Google logo
Google Jan 21, 2024

Got coupon from them send to my house for complimentary tire rotation with my oil change for my palisade, when mention about the coupon, the tech check on the computer and proceed to tell me they meant complimentary as in they'll do the service for me, not as in complimentary that meant free for rotation, try to give complimentary a different definition smh. I didn't want to argue so I said fine wherever just do the oil change when the 10 percent off, also on their coupon pamphlet there also 10 percent off for new wiper blade and i ask ... Read More

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Jan 19, 2024

I had a simple request and that was to get the price on a vehicle that was listed on cars.com. It was anything but simple in getting an answer. Prior to providing me the price, they needed to know my name, phone number and also asked for my email. After sharing some of that information with them, it was determined that they did NOT have the vehicle and it was at another location they owned. I called the other location and also got a runaround prior to providing the price. But, alas, this was not an easy request as ... Read More

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google Jan 6, 2024

Worst management ever. We went there to check the Elentra limited and we really liked the driving test. And we just wanted to get a price so we know what we are dealing with .. and then the guy comes and goes 3 4 times and gives us excuses and then lastly he told us that he could check the estimate online .. What a joke. If I wanted to check online why would I have came in the first place .. No respect for people's time.

DealerRater logo
DealerRater Jan 3, 2024

A great experience until I signed the paperwork. The car stink of cigar smoke which I was told would be taken care of...then after I closed the deal I'm told there is only one fob. This will cost me $500 to fix. But the worst part is- they don't return phone calls. Horrible-very disappointed with this dealership

Read at DealerRater

Google logo
Google Dec 19, 2023

Absolutely worse dealership possible, we took in our dad’s car for repair (all brake pads, rotors, spark plugs, tires, calipers and oil change). After the repair was completed and we were driving the car home we noticed that the engine was excessively vibrating, and check engine sign lit up. We took the car back to this dealership and they told us that one of the cylinders was miss firing and caused the coil to short and it would cost $400 to repair. This could only happen if they shorted the wiring when installing the spark plug or installed fault spark ... Read More

Google logo
Google Dec 16, 2023

Rude service workers. Waited over two hrs for an oil change. Was told nothing about the inspection of the car. No fluids were topped off. Was told they changed the light then changed it back because the old one worked again, that was a lie. Forever warranty or not I'm going to start going somewhere else for work. Completely unhappy with the service.

Google logo
Google Dec 15, 2023

Salesman put the license plate on with a gun and stripped 2/4 holes completely where he put the bolts, plate ended up flying off on the highway a month later

Get Directions

N80W12650 Leon Rd, Menomonee Falls, WI, 53051
John Amato Hyundai 43.163438, -88.0692575.